Oakland Athletics Owner Pitches One-Game First Round
People say stupid things for mass consumption.
A few years ago, Jessica Simpson voiced her confusion whether “Chicken of the Sea” was chicken or tuna. With the aid of a few drinks in 2006, Mel Gibson ranted to a host of police officers that Jewish people were responsible for all the wars in the world. Prior to the invasion of Iraq, the current administration told us the Iraqi people would welcome American forces as liberators -- and plenty of Americans believed it. More recently, VP candidate Sarah Palin said she has foreign policy experience by virtue of living in close proximity to Russia -- and she believed it.
Certainly baseball owners aren’t exempt from saying stupid things, and Oakland owner Lew Wolff stepped up to the plate Wednesday with his solution to the lengthy season and the threat of November baseball.
“I’d make it one-game-and-you’re-out for the first series,” Wolff said Wednesday. “It would be exciting. It would be great.”
What?! Is there a major league player or fan who thinks this is a great idea? After several weeks of spring training and a six-month grind through the ups and downs of the season, battling injuries and playing critical games down the stretch, is there a player alive who would want to see his title hopes vanquished in one postseason game?
The best team in baseball at season’s end could be bounced by one bad outing from its 20-game winner. Rather than have a five- or seven-game series decide which is the better team, a single error or one bad inning could determine who advances and who goes home. It’s equally unfair to the team that ekes into the playoffs with a clutch win or two in the final days, then has to play that one-game first round with one of its back-end starters taking the mound.
The best-of-five first round is bad enough. A contender will lose consecutive games numerous times throughout the season, but dropping two in a row early in the first round pretty much dooms a playoff team.
Wolff’s suggestion is typical of his peers, who often seem to have no sense of what’s best for the game. It wouldn’t take much creativity to expand the first round to a best-of-seven series. If owners were more interested in playing the World Series under more ideal weather conditions -- for the sake of both the players who invest months of work to get there and the fans who dole out big dollars to be there -- they could add a few doubleheaders to the season to end the regular season sooner, or even cut a few games from it. Owners could dump those extra days off between postseason games, which are a concession to television coverage and increase the chances of playing World Series contests in 40-degree temperatures.
Dollars dictate many of these decisions, not what’s best for the game. Although making money isn't the motivation behind Wolff’s solution, it's still a stupid idea.
